Motor Trend FlexTough Review: All-Weather Floor Mats

By Roger Holden. Researched product comparison.

All-weather mats trap water, mud, snow and sand in deep channels so the carpet underneath stays dry and the mess lifts out with the mat. The Motor Trend FlexTough Deep Dish All-Weather Floor Mats is a deep dish, trim to fit option that I would short-list for most cars and SUVs. Soaked carpets after winter, sand that vacuuming never fully removes, or kids and pets tracking in mud are the usual reasons people upgrade from carpet mats. Before you buy, it helps to know what this listing does well, where it falls short and whether it fits your car and your routine.

Key product details

Who I would recommend it to

This pick makes the most sense for most cars and SUVs. The listing highlights deep channels hold water, trim to fit, odorless rubber and front and rear set. Owners tend to point to traps snow and mud and good fit after trimming as the main reasons to choose it. If that matches how you use your car day to day, it belongs on your list.

Getting the right fit

Fit is where most all-weather floor mat set purchases go wrong. Universal mats trim to fit with scissors along marked lines; measure your footwells before trimming. Check mat height and edge design; a tall lip holds more meltwater but must not interfere with the pedals. Measuring your actual car and checking the listing's dimensions before ordering is what prevents a return.

Setting it up and looking after it

Trim universal mats gradually, test-fitting between cuts, since you cannot add material back. Secure the driver mat to the factory retention posts; a loose mat bunching under the pedals is a genuine hazard. Pull the mats out and hose them down, then let them dry fully before refitting to avoid trapped moisture. Clean under the mats occasionally, because fine grit migrates past any edge. Keep any instructions that come in the box, because mounting steps and care limits vary from model to model.

What I would check before buying

The main limitations to weigh are: trimming takes time and not a custom fit. None of these is a deal-breaker for the right buyer, but they matter if they describe your car or habits. Read the current listing details, dimensions and what comes in the box before ordering.

An alternative worth comparing

The Armor All 3-Piece is the one I would compare next. Its strength is simple universal fit, and it suits quick upgrade. Choose it instead if that description fits you better than the Motor Trend FlexTough. Read the alternative guide

Frequently asked questions

Will the Motor Trend FlexTough fit my car?

Check the dimensions and fit notes against your actual vehicle before ordering, since interior space and mounting points vary. Universal mats trim to fit with scissors along marked lines; measure your footwells before trimming.

Universal or custom-fit mats?

Custom mats follow the footwell exactly and hold more water at the edges. Universal mats cost far less and work well if you trim them carefully and anchor the driver side.

Will rubber mats smell in a hot car?

New rubber mats can have an odor for the first week or two. Air them outside before installing, and the smell fades quickly.

Can I put all-weather mats over carpet mats?

No. Stacking mats changes pedal clearance and lets the top mat slide. Remove the carpet mats first.

My buying recommendation

Choose the Motor Trend FlexTough if you are among most cars and SUVs and its limits do not get in your way. The right all-weather floor mat set is a small upgrade that you notice on every single drive.

Check the current Amazon listing

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

Compare all all-weather floor mats