How We Review Automotive Products
By Roger Holden. Updated November 12, 2026.
Every buying guide and product page on RateThisPro carries one of two labels: Hands-on review or Researched comparison. A hands-on review means Roger has used that product on his own vehicle in normal operating conditions for approximately two weeks before writing about it; a researched comparison means he worked from manufacturer documentation and other sources instead. This page explains what each label means, where the information comes from, what we will never publish, and how the site makes money, so you can decide how much weight to give a recommendation.
Our hands-on testing standard
When RateThisPro identifies a product as hands-on tested, Roger Holden personally uses that product for approximately two weeks. This allows time to evaluate its operation, usability, practical features, limitations, and performance in real-world conditions.
Our reviews explain what a product does well, where it falls short, and which buyers are most likely to benefit from it.
Products identified as researched comparisons are evaluated using manufacturer specifications, product manuals, compatibility information, safety documentation, and other relevant sources. They are not presented as personally tested.
RateThisPro does not assign arbitrary numerical product scores. Our recommendations focus on practical differences and evidence-based buying guidance.
That approximately two weeks of use happens in normal operating conditions on Roger's own vehicle, the way an owner would use the product. Comparisons and measurements are included only when he actually performed them.
Every buying guide and product page says which of the two applies to each product, and researched products are kept separate from hands-on ones. Articles that mix both say which parts come from Roger's own use, usually in the video captions and in a short note near the end of the page.
How hands-on reviews are done
Four habits shape every hands-on review you see on camera:
- Normal operating conditions: The product is installed, plugged in or used on Roger's own vehicle in normal operating conditions, the way an owner would use it, rather than demonstrated on a bench.
- Approximately two weeks, not one afternoon: Each hands-on product stays in use for approximately two weeks, so reconnect problems, battery drain, mounting and everyday annoyances have time to show up.
- Comparisons only when performed: A side-by-side comparison with similar models is included only when Roger actually ran one in the same conditions. If no comparison was done, the review doesn't suggest one.
- Measurements only when taken: Readings such as voltage, tire pressure or time to finish a job appear only when Roger actually took them with a meter, gauge or timer. If nothing was measured, no numbers are given.
How researched comparisons are built
We start with what the maker publishes: specifications, manuals, compatibility lists and firmware notes. For safety-related and diagnostic topics we go further, to the documents professionals rely on, such as manufacturer service bulletins filed with NHTSA, SAE standards, California's OBD II regulation, Battery Council International size charts and state emissions-program guidance.
Products are then compared on how well they suit a specific kind of driver and vehicle, not on a single headline number or score. Picks carry plain labels such as Best Overall, Best Budget Option or Best for Home Mechanics, and each one explains why: its strengths, where it falls short, and the buyer it suits. A dash cam for a rideshare driver and one for a weekend car need different things, so a guide names who each pick suits and what it gives up.
When a figure can't be confirmed, the page says so (for example, "check the label") instead of filling the gap with a guess.
Final editorial review before publishing
Every buying guide goes through a final editorial review before it is published or updated. Part of it runs automatically on every guide, every time the site is built: product counts, cut-off phrases, unsupported ratings and popularity claims, and mismatched verdicts stop the build until they are fixed. The rest is done by hand, product by product, against the manufacturer's own documentation.
A guide that has passed the full review shows a "Final editorial review" box with the date, the checklist and the sources used for each product. Products whose exact model or specifications can't be confirmed are removed, and the box says which ones and why.
The checklist:
- Product count matches the introduction and description
- Exact product model numbers verified against the linked listing
- Product specifications checked against manufacturer documentation
- Compatibility limitations explained for each product
- Hands-on versus researched status clearly identified
- No incomplete sentences or cut-off labels
- No unsupported star ratings or popularity claims
- Internal links work
- Affiliate disclosure is visible
- Author byline links to Roger's profile
Diagnostic and safety guidance
The check engine light assistant and the OBD2 code guides give general guidance, not a diagnosis of your vehicle. Code definitions are published only when they have been checked against manufacturer bulletins and regulations, one code at a time, with the sources listed on the page. Any other code is marked either as outside the library (manufacturer-defined, or a body, chassis or network code) or as not researched yet, and is never guessed.
Pages about jump-starting, batteries, lifting a vehicle or towing say plainly when to stop and get professional help. Your owner's manual and the product's instructions always come first.
What we never publish
To keep recommendations honest, RateThisPro does not publish:
- Test results, measurements or impressions that were not actually recorded.
- Numerical product scores or star ratings of our own, and review counts or popularity claims we can't document.
- Customer quotes or testimonials that weren't given.
- Prices, stock or deals in structured data, because they change faster than a guide is updated.
- Hands-on wording on a product Roger hasn't used.
How RateThisPro makes money
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. RateThisPro also earns commissions through the Walmart Creator program and a small number of other affiliate partners, and every page with those links says so near the link. Buying through a link doesn't change your price.
Separately, Roger makes paid product videos for Amazon brands through the RateThisPro video services. That work is listed openly on the Services page. Products made for paid video clients are not featured in buying guides, and no brand can pay for a place or a higher position in one.
Updates and corrections
Guides show the date they were published or last updated. Products are revised when a model is discontinued, a listing changes or a better-documented option appears.
If you spot an error, an outdated specification or a broken link, email Roger@RateThisPro.com with the page address. Corrections are made on the page itself.
About Roger Holden · Browse the buying guides · See a sourced code guide