P0420 Code: Catalyst System Efficiency Below Threshold (Bank 1)
By Roger Holden. Updated November 10, 2026. Researched guidance from manufacturer bulletins and OBD II rules, not a vehicle diagnosis.
Standard definition: Catalyst System Efficiency Below Threshold (Bank 1). System: Catalytic converter monitor. Severity: Moderate.
Sources for this section: [3] SAE J2012; [4] Subaru Service Information Bulletin 09-110-23; [6] Kia TSB
P0420 is one of the most-searched check engine codes, and one of the most expensive to get wrong. It means the engine computer ran its catalyst test on bank 1 and decided the converter isn't storing and cleaning exhaust gases as well as it should. That's a judgment about performance, not a direct measurement of a broken part.
The catalytic converter is often the last link in a chain. A misfire, a mixture that runs rich or lean, an exhaust leak or a slow oxygen sensor can all push the converter test into failure, and some of those problems will destroy a new converter if they're left in place. The useful question isn't "how much is a cat?" but "why did this one stop passing?"
Moderate: plan the diagnosis soon
P0420 on its own usually doesn't change how the car drives, but it will fail most emissions inspections, and the underlying cause can get worse. A converter damaged by a misfire is a symptom of a second problem. Follow your owner manual, and remember a code reader can't tell you whether driving on is safe.
Stop where safe and get help if:
- The check engine light is flashing
- The engine is misfiring, shaking or losing power
- You notice a burning smell, smoke or a glowing-hot converter
- The exhaust is suddenly much louder or the car struggles to accelerate (a possible restriction)
How the computer sets P0420
California's OBD II regulation, which sets the template for these systems, requires the computer to monitor the catalyst system for proper conversion capability and to flag it once deterioration would push emissions past a set multiple of the vehicle's certified standard. Most cars do this by comparing the oxygen sensor ahead of the converter with the one after it. A healthy converter smooths out the oxygen swings, so the rear sensor's signal stays comparatively steady; as the converter weakens, the rear signal starts to mirror the front one.
Like most emissions faults, P0420 normally sets a pending code the first time and a confirmed code, with the check engine light, if the fault is seen again on the next drive cycle in which the monitor runs. "Bank 1" is the side of the engine with cylinder 1. On a four-cylinder there is only one bank; on a V6 or V8, the matching code for the other side is P0430.
Sources for this section: [1] California Code of Regulations, Title 13 §1968.2
Common symptoms
- Check engine light on, often with no change in how the car drives
- Failed emissions or smog inspection
- Rotten-egg (sulfur) smell from the exhaust on some vehicles
- Rattling from underneath, or sluggish acceleration if a converter is breaking up or restricted
Possible causes of P0420
- Upstream engine faults: Misfires and rich or lean running overload the converter with unburned fuel or oxygen. Subaru's P0420 procedure tells technicians to diagnose misfire (P0300–P0304), fuel-trim (P0171/P0172) and oxygen or air-fuel sensor codes before going further.
- A worn or damaged catalytic converter: Converters lose efficiency with age and can be damaged by overheating from misfires or contaminated by oil or coolant burned in the engine. Kia published a bulletin covering converter replacement on certain engines that had P0420 with or without misfire codes.
- Exhaust leaks: A leak near either oxygen sensor lets outside air in and skews the readings the test depends on.
- A faulty or slow oxygen sensor: If the rear sensor (or front air-fuel sensor) misreports, a working converter can fail the test. Sensor circuit and heater codes usually point this way.
- Engine software: Some manufacturers have released calibration updates for catalyst monitor false failures. Honda's bulletin 22-040 for the 2014–16 CR-Z says parts replacement is unlikely to be needed after the software update and test drive.
- An unsuitable replacement converter: An aftermarket converter must be legal and correct for the exact vehicle; in California that means an approved part. A converter that isn't up to the job can bring the code straight back.
Sources for this section: [4] Subaru Service Information Bulletin 09-110-23; [5] Honda Service Bulletin 22-040; [6] Kia TSB
How to diagnose P0420, step by step
- Record every stored, pending and permanent code and the freeze-frame data before clearing anything. Note the coolant temperature, speed and load when P0420 set.
- Look for companion codes. Misfire, fuel-trim, oxygen-sensor and sensor-heater codes come first: fix them, then re-test the catalyst.
- Check for technical service bulletins and software updates for your exact vehicle. A dealer or the NHTSA lookup by VIN can show what has been published.
- With the exhaust cold, inspect for leaks, damaged heat shields and loose sensor mounts from the manifold back to the rear sensor.
- With a scanner that shows live data, compare the front and rear oxygen sensor signals once the engine is fully warm. Read Mode 6 catalyst test results if your scanner supports them; they show how close the result is to the limit.
- Only after those checks, have the converter itself assessed using the manufacturer's procedure. Then confirm the repair with the specified drive cycle and readiness monitors.
Record stored, pending and permanent codes and available freeze-frame data before clearing anything. Clearing codes does not fix the fault; it can erase useful evidence and reset emissions readiness monitors.
Sources for this section: [4] Subaru Service Information Bulletin 09-110-23; [5] Honda Service Bulletin 22-040
Mistakes that cost money
- Replacing the converter before fixing a misfire or fuel-mixture fault: the new part can fail the same way.
- Clearing the code just before an inspection: readiness monitors will show incomplete and the vehicle can be turned away.
- Installing "O2 sensor spacers" or tuning the test away: emissions equipment tampering is illegal and doesn't fix the converter.
- Paying for a converter that is still under warranty. The EPA lists the catalytic converter among the specified major emission control components covered for 8 years or 80,000 miles under the federal emissions warranty, subject to its conditions.
Codes often seen with it
- P0430 — Same test on bank 2 of a V6 or V8
- P0300 — Misfires that can overheat and damage the converter
- P0171 — A lean mixture that can upset catalyst readings
Scanner features that help with P0420
- Freeze-frame data
- Live front and rear oxygen sensor data
- Mode 6 on-board test results
- Readiness monitor status
Compare OBD2 scanners for home mechanics or bidirectional scan tools.
Frequently asked questions
Does P0420 always mean I need a new catalytic converter?
No. It means the catalyst test failed. Manufacturer procedures check misfire, fuel-trim, oxygen-sensor codes and exhaust leaks first, and some vehicles have software updates for the catalyst monitor.
Can I drive with a P0420 code?
Many drivers do for a short time because the car feels normal, but you can't judge safety from the code. Get it diagnosed soon, and stop safely if the light flashes or the engine shakes, loses power or smells burnt.
Will P0420 clear itself?
If the cause goes away, the light turns off after the monitor passes on three consecutive drive cycles, under the California OBD II rules. The code history can remain for a while after that.
What is the difference between P0420 and P0430?
They're the same catalyst test. P0420 is bank 1, the side with cylinder 1; P0430 is bank 2 on engines with two banks.
Is my catalytic converter covered by a warranty?
Possibly. The EPA's emissions warranty covers specified major emission control components, including the catalytic converter, for 8 years or 80,000 miles, whichever comes first, subject to conditions. Check your warranty booklet and ask a dealer.
Sources
- [1] California Code of Regulations, Title 13 §1968.2 — OBD II malfunction and diagnostic system requirements — used for: How each monitor is required to detect the fault, and when the check engine light turns on and off
- [2] US EPA — Do you drive a 1996 or newer car or light truck? (EPA-420-F-02-016) — used for: What a steady or blinking check engine light means for drivers
- [3] SAE J2012 — Diagnostic Trouble Code Definitions — used for: The standard that defines generic code numbers and descriptions
- [4] Subaru Service Information Bulletin 09-110-23 — DTC P0420 Diagnostic Procedure (via NHTSA) — used for: Code wording and the order of checks: general inspection, then misfire, fuel-trim and sensor codes
- [5] Honda Service Bulletin 22-040 — MIL is on with DTC P0420 (via NHTSA) — used for: A software update as a corrective action; parts replacement unlikely afterward
- [6] Kia TSB — catalyst efficiency deterioration with P0420 (via NHTSA) — used for: Code wording "Catalyst System Efficiency below Threshold (Bank 1)" and its link with misfire codes
- [7] US EPA — Emissions Warranties for 1995 and Newer Cars and Trucks (EPA-420-F-09-048) — used for: 8-year/80,000-mile coverage of specified major emission control components
Other code guides
- P0300: Random/Multiple Cylinder Misfire Detected
- P0171: System Too Lean (Bank 1)
- P0455: Evaporative Emission System Leak Detected (Large Leak)
- P0128: Coolant Thermostat (Coolant Temperature Below Thermostat Regulating Temperature)
- P0442: Evaporative Emission System Leak Detected (Small Leak)
- P0456: Evaporative Emission System Leak Detected (Very Small Leak)
- P0174: System Too Lean (Bank 2)
- P0301: Cylinder 1 Misfire Detected
- P0430: Catalyst System Efficiency Below Threshold (Bank 2)